रविवार, २९ सप्टेंबर, २०१३

Indian Democracy and "Right not to Vote" in today’s Social and Political Scenario

Indian Democracy and "Right not to Vote" in today’s Social and Political Scenario

Rule 49 O of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961, provides the elector a right “not to vote”. However, since enactment of this Rule, there has been a dispute about it may be because of lack of mechanism to enforce this right or the mechanism available was violating the right of secrecy of the vote.

This issue was considered by the Election Commission of India itself and the reforms in this regard viz. amendment to Rule 22 and 49 B of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961, to the effect that “on the ballot paper / ballot unit, in the column relating to the names of the candidates, after the entry relating to the last candidate, there shall be a column “none of the above”, to enable a voter to reject all the candidates”, was proposed for the first time in December, 2001, to the then Central Govt.

The same reforms were again proposed in the year 2004 by the then Chief Election Commissioner of India Mr. T S Krishnamurthy to the then Central Government. However, till date no action has been taken on the same by the successive Governments. 

Now, if the matter is viewed from another angle, even though there was no provision for right to reject the candidates on the ballot paper, the elector had option either to follow the prescribed process (which was in violation of right of secrecy) or to invalidate his/ her vote by either voting for 2/3 candidates or depositing blank ballot paper in the ballot box. Therefore, this right and the mechanism to enforce it, was available since beginning. If that is so, where are we now? Has this made any difference to the democracy? 

Now some people may say, since now separate button will appear on the voting machine, it will be easier for the economically, educationally, socially backward classes (who vote in majority in this Country) to exercise their right. To some extent this may be true also, but again question remains, what such voters will achieve ultimately? In what way this electoral activism will benefit this country? as the candidate getting maximum positive votes is going to be declared elected. So effectively we are back to the square one.

On this background, next important question is “who to blame?” For we Indians, its very easy, rather it is in our blood to blame politicians for every bad thing that happens to us in our day to day life. But where these politicians come from? Are they also not part of the same society in which we live? In Marathi we have a very famous saying “Jasa Raja tashi praja”. But I feel today’s situation is exactly opposite i.e. “Jashi Praja tasa Raja” and believe me this is not a hypothetical statement.  In recent PMC elections, the so called educated and sophisticated class of the society was also seen bargaining with the political parties for supporting a particular candidate. Such news are normally not reported in our media, but if you talk to any of such elected candidates, I am sure you will get the detailed account of the money spent by that candidate for winning the election. If this is the case in Vidhyeche Maherghar “Pune”, its better not to imagine the case of people who struggle for their daily living and in economically and socially backward states like Bihar, UP, Jharkhand, MP, etc. 

I think today’s situation was rightly predicated by late Shri. Gopal Ganesh Agarkar and his colleagues when India’s population was just around 300-350 million and therefore, he was stressing for the social reforms over political reforms.  It appears to be logical also, because unless we have a society which has the capacity to shoulder the responsibility of being a democratic state, it is like committing suicide by placing the future of the democratic country in the hands of such society.  Are we not experiencing exactly the same today?

Today we are heading towards becoming the country with highest population in this world, but at the same time the problems such as increasing economic disparity between the rich and the poor and thereby further deteriorating social health, etc. are the worst challenges Indian democracy is going to face in the coming days. Are we prepared to handle this or rather anybody is interested to tackle this?

If we look at the recent past, attempts are being made by the so called and self-declared social workers to project themselves as the true “Gandhian” and taking advantages of the anti- government sentiments of the frustrated educated youth, to challenge the very democratic principles on the pretext of fighting for the rights of the masses. Ever since the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court has been pronounced, these people are hurrying to take the credit by calling it a great victory of the society, projecting it as a great electoral reform and are themselves complementing each other for the same.  Friends, was this the dream of the great souls like Mr. Agarkar?  Was this the philosophy of Mahatma Gandhi? Was he really interested in governing the democracy in such a forceful manner? I feel such tendencies are also posing a great challenge for the Indian Democracy to survive. 

Coming back to the point, I feel today the time has come to follow the path of social reforms, reforms which will make the society more responsible, answerable, mature, than just demanding and fighting for rights. If this is achieved then this will be the real tribute to the Indian Democracy and its lifelong survival.

Hrishikesh Chitnis
h.chitnis@gmail.com